Peter Falk
Vinnie
Timothy Hutton
Frankie
Lauren Holly
Marybeth
Freddie Prinze Jr.
Tony
Tyne Daly
Ellen
Paul Lazar
Rocky
Tony Sirico
Locasso
Frank Vincent
Pete
Colm Meaney
Al Sheehan
S
Steve Sweeney
Angie
Roger Robinson
Phil
T
Tonya Tyann Tullis
Leah
Pamela Bel Anu
Jackie
B
Billy Strong
Lenny
Gene Ruffini
Maitre d'
O
Oliver Graney
Kyle
Suzanne Shepherd
Agnes
L
Luke Graney
Richie
Edoardo Ballerini
Leo
Monica Trombetta
Sharon
Murphy Guyer
Shaughnessy
Kevin Chapman
Dave
M
Mark Ethan
Ed
Rizwan Manji
Club Patron
Gano Grills
Kevin
Clare Kramer
Heather
Matt Ballard
Tommy
Terri Hawkes
Magic Lounge Waitress
J
Joey Donnelly
Keith
R
Ron Alexander
Yard Boss
Michael Harkins
Frankie's Buddy (uncredited)