Mel Gibson
Gene Carruthers
Mason Thames
Noah Reed
Julian Lerner
Eugene Wexler
Abby James Witherspoon
Sammy Devers
Noah Cottrell
Ben Driskel
Nora Zehetner
Abby Reed
Lorraine Bracco
Miss Halverson
Emma Fasano
Lilly Reed
Spencer Fitzgerald
Ronnie Harlow
Patrick Renna
Umpire
Ashley Rae Riddick
Witch
Gavin Bedell
Kevin Lampkey
Gary Weeks
Chief Hartley
Bobbi Baker
Hannah Driskel
Kelly Collins Lintz
Deb Harlow
Nico Tirozzi
Little Boy / Carruthers' Son
Lilah Pate
Ellie Evans
Kevin James
Edgar Palmer
Barbara Goodson
The Witch (voice)
Abrielle Josephine Cincotti
Emily
Nick Benas
Baseball Fan (uncredited)
Parker E. Chick
Town Kid (uncredited)
Sara Elizabeth Ezzell
Diner Patron / Pedestrian (uncredited)
Robert Fortunato
Police Officer (uncredited)
Keeley Kollmann
Mom with Kids (uncredited)
Samantha Miro
Jogger (uncredited)
Art Newkirk
Dad in Theater (uncredited)
Logan Newkirk
Book Signing Kid (uncredited)
Violet Berlus
Skip-It Girl
Lara Fontes
Lilly (voice)
Hannah Michelle
Pedestrian
Mary Clare Mitchell
Diner Patron
Lucretia Newkirk
Tourist
David Pascua
Police Officer
Veronica Russell
Baseball Spectator
Stacey Stewart
Carruthers' Wife
James Richard Wemmitt
Camera Man