Aubrey Plaza
Darius
Mark Duplass
Kenneth
Jake Johnson
Jeff
Karan Soni
Arnau
Jenica Bergere
Liz
Kristen Bell
Belinda
Jeff Garlin
Mr. Britt
Mary Lynn Rajskub
Bridget
L
Lauren Carlos
Young Darius
Basil Harris
Restaurant Manager
David Leo
Coworker
W
William Hall Jr.
Shannon
A
Alice Hung
Shift Manager
H
Hassan Cristos Messiah
Boyfriend in Car
K
Keli Schurman-Darby
Girlfriend in Car
Lynn Shelton
Uptight Mom
P
Peter Anthony Jacobs
Deputy Sheriff
E
Eli Borozan
Kid in Diner
T
Tom Ricciardelli
Security Guard
Tony Doupe
Smith
X
Xola Malik
Jones
G
Grace Arends
Darcy
K
Kimberly Durham
Linsey
S
Scott Swan
Halloween
J
John Silveira
Man at Post Office (uncredited)