Jennie Garth
Susan
Brad Rowe
Jake
Tom Arnold
Pat
Nikki Cox
Cheri (voice)
Jay Mohr
Rusty (voice)
Catherine Hicks
Ellen
David O'Donnell
Frank
Miles Elliot
Logan Davis
Ellee Jo Trowbridge
Emma
Conrad Bluth
Josh
John Colton
Reverend Paul
S
Shawn Ardalan
Elf
Keith Dobbins
Santa Claus
Brock Burnett
Rainbow
S
Shirell Ferguson-Coleman
Tahira
A
Ariana Brown
Thelma
B
Brad Barnholtz
Chauncey
Michael Healey
Troy / Ziggy