Diane Foster
Audrey
David Backus
The Orphan Killer
Matt Farnsworth
Mike
James McCaffrey
Detective Jones
John Savage
Detective Walker
Karen Young
Sister Mary
Charlotte Maier
Sister Constance
Spencer List
Young Marcus
Dana DeVestern
Young Audrey
Edward Winrow
Father Chuck
Devin Foster
Skateboarder
Ramon Villa
Sanchez the Janitor
Seif El Bawdrey
Vinny the Janitor
Olivia Rosendahl
Jump Rope Orphan
Samantha Matarante
Urban Ledgend Teen #1
April Hautea
Urban Ledgend Teen #2
Ivan Martin
Math Teacher
Margot White
Jenny Miller
Mike Doyle
Dad Miller
Golden Farnsworth
Boy Marcus
Ivy Farnsworth
Baby Audrey
Hector Lincoln
Intruder - Murderer
Allison Salvetti
Screaming Orphan
Walter Masterson
Marcus Miller
Ezra Knight
Simon - Orderly
Jon David Casey
Jerry - Orderly
Matthew Arkin
Bob - Orderly
Linda Bothwell-Murphy
Naughty Nun
Lesline Lewis
Jamaican Nun
Celina Vignaud
Orphan Kid
Michaela M. Hill
Orphan Kid
Ian Colletti
Orphan Kid Playing Basketball
Lucian Maisel
Orphan Kid Playing Basketball
Richard Charles Stevens
Robert
Kenya Brome
Reporter (uncredited)
Federico Castelluccio
Dr. Morris (uncredited)
Brian Delate
John (uncredited)
Maria Diaz
Nun (uncredited)
Michael Ray Escamilla
Hector (uncredited)
Matthew Gooley
Orderly (uncredited)
Carrie Needham
Mike's Mother (uncredited)
Drew Needham
Policeman (uncredited)
Karen Olivo
Angie (uncredited)
Josh Pesin
Policeman (uncredited)
Jeff Velez
News Photographer (uncredited)
William Wayne
Marcus' Orderly (uncredited)