Guy Pearce
Father Peter
Vadhir Derbez
Father Daniel
Stephen Lang
Archbishop
Brady Jenness
Charlie Giroux
Robin Bartlett
Helen
Keith David
Father Louis
Chris Galust
Young Peter
Acoryé White
George
James Healy Jr.
Forensic Psychologist
Heath Freeman
Mr. Miller
Hannah Alline
Mrs. Miller
Tristan Riggs
Nicholas Miller
Stephanie Rhodes
Charlie's Mother
Major Dodge
Charlie's Father
Evangeline Griffin
Nellie
Johari Turner
Aaron
Björgvin Arnarson
Carson
Grace E Gonzalez
Jazzy
Seth Gutierrez
Sherman
Gail Cronauer
Archbishop's Secretary
Mykle McCoslin
Administrator
Gary Lee Reed
Priest
Garrett Schweighauser
Father Dunleavy
Silas De La Rosa
Young Daniel
Ethan Pogue
Young Daniel's Friend #1
Joe Colaleo
Young Daniel's Friend #2
Riley Irvin
Young Daniel's Friend #3
Cecilia Okoye
Guard #1
David Opegbemi
Guard #2
Jancey Sheats
News Reporter
Craig Cole
Police Officer #2 (uncredited)
Braden Balazik
Detention Center Kid (uncredited)
Angela Destro
Detention Center Doctor (uncredited)
Riley Fitzgerald
Juvenile Detention Kid (uncredited)
Isaiah Finley
Detention Guard (uncredited)