Bette Midler
Winifred Sanderson
Sarah Jessica Parker
Sarah Sanderson
Kathy Najimy
Mary Sanderson
Whitney Peak
Becca
Belissa Escobedo
Izzy
Lilia Buckingham
Cassie
Froy Gutierrez
Mike
Sam Richardson
Gilbert
Doug Jones
Billy Butcherson
Tony Hale
Mayor / Reverend Traske
Hannah Waddingham
The Witch Mother
Taylor Henderson
Young Winifred
Nina Kitchen
Young Mary
Juju Journey Brener
Young Sarah
Thomas Fitzgerald
John Pritchett
Brett Cramp
Mr. Pritchett
Kim Niemi
Townsperson
Alison Weller
Townsperson
Holly Cinnamon
Townsperson
Patrick French
Townsperson
Charlotte Peed
Mrs. Smith
Ed Peed
Mr. Smith
Austin J. Ryan
Young Billy Butcherson
Michael Tow
Mr. Wilke
Brina
School Secretary
Brian Wiles
Rob
Owen Earls
Liam
Skyla Sousa
Teen Winifred
Aiden Torres
Teen Mary
Emma Kaufman
Teen Sarah
Chhoyang Cheshatsang
Thom
Jaylin Pryor
Teen Gilbert
Marissa Carpio
Food Stall Woman
Naheem Garcia
Fred
Dan Finnerty
Lucas
Ginger Minj
Drag Queen Winifred
Kornbread Jeté
Drag Queen Mary
Kahmora Hall
Drag Queen Sarah
Ryan Rosenthal
Glenn
Juvan Elisma
Alex
Jen D'Angelo
Liam's Mom
Mark Fichera
Scary Scarecrow
Jordan von Netzer
Roman Soldier
Mark Hawker
Puppeteer
Shane Dzicek
Puppeteer
CJ Walsh
Puppeteer
David Torres Jr.
Teacher (uncredited)