Joey McIntyre
Tony
Mila Kunis
Tina
Krista Allen
Maddy
Priscilla Lopez
Josephina Vitale
Adrian Grenier
Michael
John Fiore
Mr. Nunzio
Dean Edwards
Father Mark
Jon Bernthal
Dominic Fabrizzi
Richard Portnow
Vinnie Black
Sebastian Stan
Johnny Nunzio
Clement Fowler
Uncle Louie
Matthew Saldivar
Barry
Richard Robichaux
Joey
Mary Testa
Sister Clare
Tony Travis
Zeppo the Bartender
Daisy Eagan
Donna Marsala
Kim Director
Connie
Guillermo Díaz
Raphael
Lenny Venito
Sal
Donnie Keshawarz
Donnie Dulce
Vanessa Paradise
Marina Galino
Lou Martini Jr.
Ralph
Mariann Tepedino
Mariann
Letty Serra
Grandma Nunzio
Miari Peterson
Celeste
George Papas
Alter Boy
S. Michael Bellomo
Cop
Anthony Colangelo
Young Joey
Aristedes Philip DuVal
The Pez Brothers-Cinema Owners
Paul Heyman
Gino
Haley Joel
The Blonde
Richard Mamary
The Limo Driver
Lisa Miller
Patty
Salvatore Norris
Carmine Cannoli
Megan O'Leary
Waitress
Victoria Lauren Paccione
Young Tina
Joanna Parson
Band member
Nick Raynes
Mickey
Laura Jean Salerno
Babydoll
Michael Straka
Stickey