Kyle Davis
Jeff
Devin McGinn
Charlie
G
Gregg Lawrence
Captain Olaf
Edmund Lupinski
Professor Lake
Leah McKendrick
Chelsea
Richard Riehle
Mr. Snodgrass
Oren Skoog
Henry
Martin Starr
Clarence
Alexi Wasser
Nicole
E
Ethan Wilde
Starspawn
Jessica Kinney
Susie
Harry Karp
Jimbo
D
Douglas Jantzen Jr.
Cult Leader
Barak Hardley
Paul
Todd Duffey
Cult member #1
Sujata Day
Stacy Rahman
J
Justin Giddings
Comedic Cult Member #1
Bryce Hurless
Comic book kid
M
Max Huber
Bum