Ray Liotta
Adult Mickey
Rory Culkin
Roger
Trevor Morgan
Mickey
Tania Raymonde
Kelly
Willa Holland
Jamie
Lauren Holly
Marilyn
Lori Petty
Deputy Fryman
M. Emmet Walsh
Chuck Ireland
Scott Aaronson
Baseball Coach
Matt Abshire
Bobby
Michael R. Aubele
Dad
Nicholas Brady
Young Roger
Andrew Bryniarski
Gang Member
Seymour Cassel
Poppy
Ricardo Chavira
Dr. Boogie
Mercedes Connor
Admittance Nurse
Cris D'Annunzio
Principal Motley
Keith David
Officer L.
Dan Fastuca
Gang Member
Kevin Gage
Short Order Cook
Michael Govia
The Minister
Ryan R. Johnson
ER Doctor
Jay Karnes
Adult Roger
Drake Kemper
Danny
Madison Lanesey
Maddy Straka
Meritt Latimore
Pirates Fan
Louis Lombardi
Short Order Cook
Zander Lyons
Young Baseball Player
Ryan March
Mets Catcher
Christopher May
Coach Johnson
Michael O'Keefe
Dr. Stuart
Katie Piel
Jr. Nurse K. Copland
Jax Pyle
Umpire
Alisa Schulz
Sally the Waitress
Patrick Sebes
Bobby Straka
Max Van Ville
Catcher
Zakk Wylde
Gang Leader
Geoffrey Gould
ER Doctor (uncredited)
Bill Mikita
First Base Coach (uncredited)
David Morse
Pirates Fan (uncredited)