Tom Arnold
Nick
Candace Cameron Bure
Holly
Christopher Wiehl
Peter
Barbara Niven
Ginny
Matt Walton
Ben Richards
Allan F. Nicholls
Earl
Kaily Smith Westbrook
Brenda
Heather Remick
Della
B
Bruce Bouchard
Mr. Covell
R
Richard Waterhouse
Mr. Jennings
T
Taylor Ampatiellos
Willy
L
Lillian Pritchard
Young Holly
A
Ari Larson
Young Peter
P
Parma
Nick's Dog
G
Gary Boyles
Office worker (uncredited)
D
Dave Kulvete
Elf waiter (uncredited)
E
Emily George Lyons
Willy's Mom (uncredited)
R
R.W. Martin
Townsperson (uncredited)