Michael Ian Black
Michael
Michael Showalter
Michael
David Wain
David
Nina Hellman
David's Cousin's Wife / Poker Wife / Brooklyn Girl
Josh Hamilton
David's Cousin Greg
Rosadel Varela
Taco Woman
Zach Galifianakis
Santa
Francie Swift
Santa's Wife
Peter Salett
Sherpa / Indian / Terrorist / Policeman / Park Dancer
Bradley Cooper
Yoga Student / Satan
Paul Rudd
John
Zak Orth
Turkey Hunter / Christmas Caroler / Inspector / Enos / Friend
A.D. Miles
Christmas Caroler / Pilgrim / Wiffleball Player / Fishing Husband
Martha Black
Christmas Caroler
Heidi Neurauter
Christmas Caroler / College Buddy / Angel / Brooklyn Girl
Scott Sowers
Dad / Poker Player
Joe Lo Truglio
Johnson / Indian / Wiffleball Player / Mugger
Angela Galyean
Pilgrim
Ian Helfer
College Buddy / Office Person / General Thornbush
Marisa Ryan
College Buddy
Christina Kirk
College Buddy / Terrorist / Fishing Wife
Leo Allen
College Buddy
Jenny Maguire
Office Person / Lady Richington
Todd Holoubek
Office Person
Joanne Solomon
Office Person
Ben Shenkman
Hans
Sam Rockwell
Pizza Guy
Glenn Kessler
Jarvis the Butler
Stuart Blumberg
Major Gentry
Ali Marsh
Maid
Callie Thorne
Yoga Teacher
Elizabeth Banks
Yoga Student
Amy Miles
Yoga Student
Matt Ballard
Poker Player / Park Dancer
Julie Bowen
Mother Nature
Amy Carlson
Park Dancer
John Roberts
Park Dancer
Julie Dingman
Park Dancer
Seth Herzog
Park Dancer
Amy Rice
Cat Girl