Martin Landau
Robert
Ellen Burstyn
Mary
Adam Scott
Mike
Elizabeth Banks
Alex
Har Mar Superstar
Peter (as Sean Tillmann)
K
Kali Cook
Cute Girl
C
Chris Wiig
Co-Worker #1 (as Christopher Why)
M. Michele Phillips
Co-Worker #2
T
Tina Dixon
Post Woman (as Christine Dixon)
Mary Husar
Co-Worker #3
Scott Beehner
Co-Worker #4
T
Todd Fink
Fancy Waiter
R
Ross Brockley
Grumpy Carriage Driver
A
Alex Curbeam
Damien Montgonmery
M
Michael Leach Jr.
Sled Kid #2
N
Nick Hernandez
Sled Kid #3
Leo Fitzpatrick
Pharmacist
J
Judith Kathryn Hart
Jacky
J
Jules Blight
Lisa
M
Mark Booker
Harold
M
Mark Kresl
Rufus
Z
Zoey Newman
Michelle
J
James Devney
Buck
M
Melissa Jarecke
Party Woman
S
Sean O'Connell
Young Mike
R
Randi-Shane Knox
Young Alex