Elizabeth Olsen
Martha
Sarah Paulson
Lucy
Hugh Dancy
Ted
John Hawkes
Patrick
Brady Corbet
Watts
Louisa Krause
Zoe
Christopher Abbott
Max
Maria Dizzia
Katie
Julia Garner
Sarah
Adam David Thompson
Bartender
Allen McCullough
Man in Home #2
Lauren Molina
Cult Member
Louisa Braden Johnson
Cult Member
Tobias Segal
Cult Member
Gregg Burton
Man in Home #1
Barbara Aragon
Donald E. Benjamin
Stacie A. Blaut
Carole L. Brookman
Heather Boyd
Ellie Brooks
Richard S. Clark Jr.
Sal Crescitelli
Josephine E. DeSimone
Jarret Featherbay
Jill Halpern Steingart
Jonathan Huppke
Louis H. Jawitz
Fred A. Kahn
Heather M. Kayal
Party Guest
Jin Kyung Kim
Ava K. Levy-Lynn
Franco C. Lisacchi
Nancy I. Mahoney
Joanne McDonough
John F. McDonough
James P. Minoux
Annette Nazari
J. Clifford Noonan
Claire Payevsky
Dalton Powell
Jackson Powell
Peyton Powell
Samantha Powell
Christopher Roe
Aziza O. Simpkins
Judith M. Skordinski
Jessica K. Smith
Beth Stephens
Jot Stephens
Jennifer L. Vega
Rahmel Thomas Walker
Rachel Bernstein
Interviewee (uncredited)
Michael Chmiel
Scruffy Man (uncredited)
Diana Masi
Cult Member (uncredited)