Carl Crew
Jeffrey Dahmer
Christopher 'CJ' Smith
Young Jeffrey Dahmer
Donna Stewart Bowen
Mother
Jeanne Bascom
Grandmother
Cassidy Phillips
Steven
G-Jo Reed
Steve
Rowdy Jackson
Richard
Andrew Christian English
Anthony
Don Jose Christian
Anthony
Douglas Moore
Raymond
Lando St. Clair
Edward
Dominic Anthony
Ernest / Matt
John Anthony Williams
David
Peter Napoles
Konerak
Aaron Braxton
Tracy
Alex Scott
Ronald
Keith Gearhart
James
Cornelius Williams
Bobby
Rhonno Ket
Sounthome
Melanite Haymon
Sandra
Michelle Silveira
Glenda
Christian Voss
Bar Pick-Up
Jordan Cox
Baby
Jill Cox
Lady with Baby
Laura Tesone
Lady in Car
Rick Bower
Clergyman
Marklen Kennedy
Composite Victim
Lance Mitchell
Prostitute / Victim
Lisa Marks
Probation Officer
Deane Nelson
Police Officer
Lana Lloyd
Police Officer
Jason Hurst
Police Officer
Jeff Theis
Police Officer
Mario Capra
Police Officer
Marz Jagger
Police Officer
Michael Millazo
Police Officer
Suzie Campbell
Police Officer
Vonda Shrader
Police Officer
Todd Fournier
Policeman #1
Brian Murphy
Policeman #2
Kent Moyer
Policeman #3
Lendy Jones
Policeman #4
Walter McBride
Policeman #5
Enrique Gavilanes
Policeman #6
L.P. Brown III
Policeman #7
Bredy Gamble
Policeman #8
Deborah Kellar
Neighbor #1
Hilda Boulware
Neighbor #2
David Angelis
Bartender #1
Kimberly Krank
Bartender #2
Chuck Record
Bartender #3
John Collins
Jeffrey's Dad (voice)
Sherman Sherman
Victim's Mom (voice)
Josephine O'Keefe
Lady Bartender (voice)