David Bowles
Waiter
James Eckhouse
Dr. Doctor Willard Bliss
Kathryn Erbe
Lucretia Garfield
L
Ladislav Gergel
Jim Garfield
Shuler Hensley
James Garfield
Logan Hillier
Dr. Reyburn
J
John Hutton
James Blaine
Will Janowitz
Charles Guiteau
J
Josef Karas
Conkling's Valet
Adam LeFevre
Chester Arthur
Sean Mahon
Roscoe Conkling
Michael Murphy
Narrator
Ted Otis
Reporter
Daniel Pearce
Silas Boynton
Karina Rchichev
Mary 'Mollie' Garfield
D
Dan Rowland
Harry Garfield
Joe Weintraub
Joseph Stanley Brown