James Murray
Judas
Jeremy Guskin
Jesus
Ronney Ascher
Manuel Hossenfeffer Rodriguez
Marti Cooney
Mrs. Baker / Hoagie Woman
Laurence Frommer
Mr. Baker
Elizabeth Wood
Mary / Disgusted Angel
David Skigen
Joseph
Sal Vulcano
Lawn Mower Boy / Extra
Matthew Glass
Larry
Hank Poje
James Peterson / God / Smitty
Jonah Zeiger
Vinny (as Jonah Zieger)
Kelley Rae O'Donnell
Play Angel
David Hubbell
Herbie Falafen
James P. Murray
George
Lino Alvarez
Dr. Puglia / Yelling Angel
Pete Barker
Moses
Ken Dray
Noah
Dennis Meehan
Ham Slicing Boy
Hillary Ayn Ryan
Sandy Weinberg (as Hillary Gouse)
Lyle Silversmith
Max Weinberg
Jason Hom
Ezekiel Weinberg
Jonathan Beatrice
Scared Angel
Colin Liander
Roman Centurion / Extra
Michael Rigby
Roman Centurion
Patrick Nicholas
Satan
Christopher Morgan
Bar Wiping Boy
Bennato Pennella
Bar Tender Assistant
Andrew Hanniffy
Extra
Brian J. Jamieson
Extra
Glenn Klein
Extra
Cara S. Liander
Extra
Robert Liander
Extra
Kenneth Robert Marlo
Extra (as Kenneth Miller)
Matty O'Shea
Extra
Michael Onorato
Extra
Heather Taylor-Simpson
Extra
Jim Walsh
Extra
Pam Bernstein
Extra