Aaron Tveit
Charlie Carroll
Kal Penn
Brice
Abby Elliott
Angela
Annaleigh Ashford
Anne
Kelen Coleman
Lorelei
Haviland Morris
Angela's Mom
Chris Elliott
Angela's Dad
L
Lauren Miller Rogen
Kathy
Jessica Rothe
Mary
Lewis Black
Charlie's Therapist
Shane McRae
Vince (as Shane Mcrae)
Julia Eringer
Workaholic Hottie
M
Misty Gonzalez
Background
S
Scott Hedley
Presidential Debate Attendee
Emily Althaus
Date #3
Vasthy Mompoint
Date #2
Liz Holtan
Date #1
G
Guy Olivieri
Restaurant Worker
Jake Paque
Magic 8-Ball Manager
Sulekha Naidu
Date #4