Anya Taylor-Joy
Thomasin
Ralph Ineson
William
Kate Dickie
Katherine
Harvey Scrimshaw
Caleb
Ellie Grainger
Mercy
Lucas Dawson
Jonas
Julian Richings
Governor
Bathsheba Garnett
The Witch
Sarah Stephens
The Witch, Young
Daniel Malik
Black Phillip (voice)
Axtun Henry Dube
Samuel
Athan Conrad Dube
Samuel
Vivien Moore
Lead Coven Witch
Karen Kaeja
Coven Witch
Brandy Leary
Coven Witch
Rebecca Hope Terry
Coven Witch
Carrie Eklund
Coven Witch
Madlen Sopadzhiyan
Coven Witch
Paul Kenworthy
Militia Man 1
Mark Millmna
Militia Man 2
Andy Volpe
Militia Man 3
Phillip Wynne
Wampanoag Man
Annawon Weeden
Wampanoag Man
Michael O'Hare
Pipe Smoker
Chris Messier
Shepherd
Ron Young
Old Slater
Nora Messier
Shepherdess
Bill Rudder
Settler
Grace Duffy
Settler
Sophie Bermudez
Settler
Corrine Manning
Settler
Heather Huntington Stewart
Chamber Pot Woman
Jeff Smith
Nobelman (uncredited)