Glenn Close
Diana
Elizabeth Banks
Isabel
Eric Bogosian
Henry
Jesse Bradford
Alec
Matthew Davis
Mark
Andrew Howard
Ian
Thomas Lennon
Marshall
John Light
Peter
Susan Malick
Rachel
James Marsden
Jonathan
Michael Murphy
Jesse
Denis O'Hare
Andrew
Isabella Rossellini
Liz
George Segal
Rabbi Mendel
Rufus Wainwright
Jeremy
Angel Desai
Laura
Katie Kreisler
Helen
Regina Schneider
Amanda
Jim Parsons
Oliver
Philip Tabor
Paul
Jonathan Walker
Michael
Chandler Williams
Juilliard Macbeth
Bess Wohl
Juilliard Lady Macbeth
Daniel Neiden
Wedding Rabbi
Rachel Siegel
Autograph Seeker
Jordi Vilasuso
Benjamin's Ex
Nat DeWolf
Benjamin's Ex
Joel de la Fuente
Benjamin's Ex
Melanie R. Orr
Scorned Woman
Jane Nichols
Guest 1
Don Fitzgerald
Built Guy
Meghan Glennon
Party Girl
Winsome Brown
SNL Writer
Michael Goldstrom
SNL Writer
Steven Glenn
Guest 2
Alice Tan Ridley
Subway Singer
Caroline Clay
Subway Woman
Cindy Adams
Self
Alexander Lange
Guest 3
Manny Siverio
Subway Mugger
Frank Shattuck
EMT
D'Vorah Bailey
Police Officer
Jan Ellis
Hospital Receptionist
Liza Colón-Zayas
Ana