Paul McCloskey
Wayne Montgomery
Barbara Lessin
Andrea Montgomery
Brinke Stevens
Julie
Bruce DeSantis
Todd Montgomery
Emily Spiegel
Monica Montgomery
Michael J. Panichelli Jr.
Detective John Haynes
Jeff Watson
Joe Mitchell
Tanisha Dungee
Teresa Mitchell
Benjamin P. Ablao Jr.
Detective Chris Dolendo
Joey Garrison
Jared
Stacey Lowery
Olivia Hutton
Dave Wascavage
Richard Kemmerling
Melissa Torrence
Karen Wilson
Beth Sikma
Kim
Erick Kniesler
Jonathan
Bill Jackson
Matt
Niki Kehagias
Marcia
Shree Holman
Diana
Kate Holloway
Holly
Jay Cusack
Jeffrey
Yolanda Irizarry
Juanita
Debra Lee Wylie
Victim
Fran Slaczka
Women's Retreat Victim #1
Sue Morrow
Women's Retreat Victim #2
Karen Kennedy
Women's Retreat Victim #3
Mary Brown
Women's Retreat Victim #4
Steve Brown
Pastor Vernon Cole (deleted scenes)
Denise Smiley
Carolyn Jackson (deleted scenes)
John Larsen
Ron Hayford (deleted scenes)
Chris Keller
Amy (deleted scenes)
Meredith Fagioli
Juanita (voice) (deleted scenes)
Anthony Spadaccini
Derek Wilson (deleted scenes)
Mario DeSantis
Mike Montgomery (deleted scenes)
Keith Pyle
Doug Montgomery (deleted scenes)
James J. Ward
Scott Ratliff (deleted scenes)