Hilarie Burton Morgan
Katherine
Tyler Hilton
Caleb
Randy Travis
Mr. Greenhall
Markie Post
Lilly
Ed Asner
Papa Noel
Brody Rose
Zach
Ariana Neal
Sienna
Cannon Bosarge
Bryce
Griff Furst
Josh
C
Colin Bates
Young Caleb
Samantha Beaulieu
Park Ranger Beth
J
Jacob Etter
Flashback Kid
Odessa Feaster
Local Woman
Dana Gourrier
Janelle
L
Leticia Jimenez
Kathryn's Assistant
M
Mary Katherine Oglesby
Young Katherine
L
Lisa Raziano
Pageant Attendee
A
Angela M. Thomas
Receptionist
Allen Boudreaux
Store Patron (uncredited)
J
John C. Coffman
Office Worker (uncredited)
J
Jay Florsheim
Bonfire Goer (uncredited)
B
Bria Hobgood
Extra (uncredited)
Tommy Sheppard
Bonfire Goer (uncredited)