Tony Goldwyn
Joshua
F. Murray Abraham
Father Tardone
Kurt Fuller
Father Pat Hayes
Stacy Edwards
Maggie
Giancarlo Giannini
The Pope
Eddie Bo Smith Jr.
Theo
Michael Guido
Aaron
Matt Zeigler
Kevin
Colleen Camp
Joan Casey
Marc Grapey
Steve Casey (as Mark Grapey)
Rich Komenich
Ray Persini
Dale Calandra
Leo Persini
Cedric Young
Charlie
Tim Grimm
Bishop Anderson
Jordan Allen
Michael Reed
James Meeks
Muntoe
Bernie Landis
Rabbi Szeneth
John Sierros
Policeman (credit only)
David Pasquesi
Eli Cohen
Tom Brainard
Young Pastor
Tim Decker
Reverend Daily
Linsey Page Morton
Paulina
Beth Lacke
Sally
Tom Roland
Cardinal Riccardo
Coburn Goss
Father Delorenzo (as Coby Goss)
Jim Carrane
Father Tumelo
Ilio Bruno
Cardinal Napoli
Barrie D. Buckner Jr.
Henry (as Barrie D. Buckner)
Jason Borgardt
Randall
Ken Stimson
Reverend Williams
Bob O'Donnell
Bishop Representative
Tai Anderson
Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"
Brad Avery
Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"
David Carr
Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"
Mark Lee
Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"
Mac Powell
Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"
David Barnes
Lost and Found Parishioner
Jordan Teachout
Sunday School Student