Gretchen Mol
Bettie Page
Chris Bauer
Irving Klaw
Jared Harris
John Willie
Sarah Paulson
Bunny Yeager
Cara Seymour
Maxie
David Strathairn
Estes Kefauver
Lili Taylor
Paula Klaw
John Cullum
Preacher in Nashville
Matt McGrath
Nervous Man
Austin Pendleton
Teacher
Norman Reedus
Billy Neal
Dallas Roberts
Scotty
Victor Slezak
Minister in Miami
Tara Subkoff
June
Kevin Carroll
Jerry Tibbs
Ann Dowd
Edna Page
Michael Gaston
Mr. Gaughan
Jefferson Mays
Little John
Peter McRobbie
Gangel
Dan Snook
Mr. Grimm
Jonathan M. Woodward
Marvin
Greg Ainsworth
Man on Street
John Boyd
Jack
David Call
Guy #1 at Party
Geoffrey Cantor
Director at Audition
Max Casella
Howie
Alejandro Chabán
Armand
Jaymie Dornan
Young Jimmy Page
Teddy Eck
Charlie
Jack Gilpin
Roy Page
Dan Haft
Photographer #1
Lars Hanson
Detective Farrell
Daniel Haughey
Battle
Frank Hopf
Jack Kramer
Ed Jewett
Bookstore Owner
Aaron Lazar
Jake
Alexandra LeClair
Young Goldie
Heather Litteer
Model
Gary Lundy
Guy #2 at Party
Edmund Lyndeck
Father Egan
Marisa Malone
Drunken Woman at Party
Shelly Mars
Photographer #2
Christopher McCann
Dr. Henry
Randy Miles
Photographer #3
Molly Moore
Young Bettie
Joseph Mosso
Art
James J. Pollock
Court Official
Naelee Rae
Young Love
Alicia Sable
Goldie
Ean Sheehy
Director at Screen Test
Kohl Sudduth
Police Officer
Ashley Terrill
Marion
John Hans Tester
Producer at Screen Test
Benjamin Walker
Jim
Michael Boydston-White
Choir Singer