Ben Stiller
Mike Maxwell
Linda Cardellini
Gretchen Rice
Homer Janson
Justice Kicklighter
Ulysses Janson
Junior Kicklighter
Arlo Janson
Simon Kicklighter
Atlas Janson
Samuel Kicklighter
Toby Huss
Al Wilmington
Maren Heisler
Mia
Edi Patterson
Rose
Tim Heidecker
Deputy Cox
Ari Graynor
Carol (voice)
Ashley Rae Spillers
Barbara (voice)
Lucy Zukaitis
Julia
Bryant Carroll
Security Guard
Louis Heisler
Anthony Biniak
Noah Fisher
Gus
Isabella Steele
Mia’s Friend
Dominick Marrone
Reverend Logan
Vasily Deris
Theater Manager
Jerome Agean
Radio Announcer
Estelle Lapina
Prop Kid #1
Brooks Roseberry
Prop Kid #2
Will Daly
Prop Kid #3
Evan Bartos
Prop Kid #4
Alexander Louis
Gingerbread Man
Rodrigo Almarales
Gingerbread Man Dancer
Jeff Janson
Steve Kicklighter
Melissa Gelfin
Janet Kicklighter
Jenny McManus
Party Guest (uncredited)