Sean Astin
Narrator
Mallory Everton
Cora / Townswoman
Whitney Call
Robert Failure Gladstone / Charlotte / Temperance
Matthew Meese
Captain Evander Lillianquist / Willy / Flour Man / Jeff
Jason Gray
Chesterton / Doctor / Proprietor / Kit Carson
Natalie Madsen
Aveline / Madam Molly
Stephen Meek
Elijah / William / Thirsty Man
Stacey Harkey
Terrence / Clarence / Fan #2 / The Ringmaster
Jeremy Warner
Hank / The Lion
Adam Berg
Percival / Polio Joe / Henry / Billy / Mime
James Perry
Angus / Julian / Johnny River / Fan #1 / Porch Man / Papa
Matt Moen
Strongman
Ruth Clarke
Johnny River Sr.
Molly Schofield
Sarah Jenkins
Macy Knapp
Teen Aveline
Miley Knapp
Young Aveline
Sonja Call
Grandma Jenkins
Alan Call
Grandpa Jenkins
Cruz Jolley
Jenkins Boy
Asher Chappell
Glenn the Ranch Hand
Chris Dwight
Assassin
Bryson Alejandro
Simon Bolivar
Chase Montierth
Poor Chap Elijah Refused to Carry Across the River
Lorymore Warner
First-born Son