Bethany Joy Lenz
Lucy Hardgrove
Kristoffer Polaha
Jack Huston
Colton Little
Claude Lancaster
A.K. Benninghofen
Margaret
Annabelle Borke
Ava Hayward
Jennifer Cortese
Peggy
Jonathan Frakes
Winston
David Alexander
William West
Tommy Cresswell
Michael Balaban
Robert Picardo
Harold Balaban
Caity Brewer
Becca
P
Philena Gilmer
Sandra
Mary Elizabeth McDonough
Director
Alphie Hyorth
Angel
R
Ray Fawley
James's Father
Bobbie Peterson
Tree Lighting Patron
B
Barbara Nuss Stiles
Present Day Tourist
J
Josh Yarusinsky
Waiter
Wes Brown
Charlie
Rachel Boston
Lucy, Actress