Adam Pally
Charlie
Jordana Brewster
Rosie Schreiber
Xosha Roquemore
Emma
Peter Dager
Max Schreiber
Reid Scott
Phil Schreiber
Rhys Coiro
Ray
Dylan Penn
Jess
Peter Grosz
Trey Reynolds
J
Joy Decker
Mrs. Claus
Connor Murray
Jason Dubin
Roger
J
Judy Rosenblatt
Mrs. Dunn
S
Sabrina Almeida
Waitress (uncredited)
J
Jacob Epstein
Delivery Guy
F
Fernando Villegas
Ricky
Aidan J. Lawrence
Quinn
A
Adam Bramson
Jesus
C
C.J. Riggs
Nero
A
Ashley Rose Nicholas
Laurissa
O
Owen Jackson Jr.
Santa-con Santa (uncredited)