David Howard Thornton
The Mean One
Krystle Martin
Cindy
Chase Mullins
Officer Burke
J
John Bigham
Doc
E
Erik Baker
Sheriff Hooper
Amy Schumacher
Mayor McBean
F
Flip Kobler
Lou
Christopher Sanders
Narrator (voice)
S
Stephanie Bates
Stephanie
Robert DiTillio
Don
Rachel Winfree
Bartender
Jessie Holder Tourtellotte
Anchorwoman
Allyson Sereboff
Nurse
Saphina Chanadet
Young Cindy
S
Steven Busby
Anchorman
V
Victoria Ippolito
Waitress Emily
A
Alexandra Vaughan
Hiker Girl
B
Brian Waters
Dick Santa
Andrew Fultz
Dick Santa 2
E
Ernie Charles
EMT
W
Whit Spurgeon
Bus Driver
Christine DiTillio
Martha
T
Tina Van Berk
Mom
J
Josh Arnold
Delivery Driver
K
Kale Shepherd
Santa Con Santa
Aubrey Mozino
Christmas Box Influencer
Molly Flanagan
Mrs. Claus Influencer
e
elizabeth lamorte-wright
Missing Person