Skyler Samuels
Gabby Petito
Evan Hall
Brian Laundrie
Thora Birch
Nichole Schmidt
Douglas Taurel
Joe Petito
Monica Moore Smith
Rose
Matisha Baldwin
Shaw
Samuel Whitten
Jim Schmidt
Lonzo Liggins
Officer #1
Brian Kinney
Officer #2
Melanie Nelson
Reporter
Nikki SooHoo
Miranda
Aaron Groben
John
Tyonne Chambers
Friend
Jan Broberg Felt
Attorney
Dymone Priestley
Produce Guy
Kimberly Houk
Network Reporter
Stacey Ann Turner
Tara Petito
Bridger Johnson
TJ
Pamela Beheshti
FBI Agent
Bryan Bernardi
Violence Witness Restaurant Customer
Ron Beth
Search and Rescue
Mario DeAngelis
FBI Agent
John Forker
Restaurant Patron
Dustin Freeman
FBI Agent
Alireza Mirmontazeri
Undercover Cop
Joe Byron Symes
Angry Citizen
Cathy Tidwell
Roberta Laundrie
Matthew P. Watts
Officer
Chad Wright
Sheriff
Craig Gregersen
Teton County Sheriff (uncredited)
Rowan Cooper
Reporter